When it comes to premium modular motorcycle helmets, the Schuberth C5 and Shoei Neotec 3 are two of the most advanced and well-regarded options available. At Moto Central, as a proud retailer of both brands, we aim to provide an unbiased and detailed comparison to help you choose the right helmet for your riding needs.
Safety and Construction
Both helmets are certified to the latest ECE 22.06 standard, guaranteeing the highest level of safety. However, there are distinct differences in their construction and performance in safety tests.
- Schuberth C5: The standard C5 features a fibreglass shell reinforced with carbon fibre, while the C5 Carbon version boasts a full carbon fibre shell for enhanced strength and reduced weight. It scored 4 stars in SHARP safety tests, with a 100% success rate in keeping the chin bar closed during impacts.
- Shoei Neotec 3: Constructed using Shoei's Advanced Integrated Matrix (AIM) shell, which combines fibreglass and organic fibres. It achieved a 5-star SHARP rating, with the chin bar staying closed 97% of the time.
Conclusion: While the Shoei Neotec 3 leads in SHARP safety ratings, the Schuberth C5 offers an equally robust design with a perfect chin bar closure score. Riders looking for a lightweight option should consider the Carbon version of the C5.
Comfort and Fit
Both helmets excel in rider comfort, but their approaches differ slightly.
- Schuberth C5: This helmet features a customisable interior with removable and washable padding. Its Anti-Roll-Off System enhances fit and security, while the ratchet-style chin strap is quick and easy to adjust. Noise levels are impressively low, with only 85dB recorded at 62mph on a naked bike.
- Shoei Neotec 3: Equipped with plush lining, Noise Isolators in the cheek pads, and a snug neck roll to block wind noise. The micro-ratchet strap system is intuitive and secure, while removable ear pads make it compatible with communication systems. Though slightly noisier than the C5, it remains very quiet overall.
Conclusion: The Schuberth C5 offers unparalleled noise reduction, making it ideal for touring riders. The Shoei Neotec 3 stands out for its thoughtful integration of features like Noise Isolators and easy communication system compatibility.
Ventilation
Good ventilation is crucial for rider comfort, particularly on long rides or in warmer climates.
- Schuberth C5: Features dual chin vents and a top vent with a two-stage slider. Internal channels and a flap system help direct airflow effectively, but the vent controls could be more intuitive.
- Shoei Neotec 3: Offers a two-position chin vent and an improved top vent that are easy to operate even with gloved hands. Its consistent airflow makes it particularly effective at higher speeds.
Winner: The Shoei Neotec 3 takes the lead with its glove-friendly controls and superior usability.
Communication System Integration
Both helmets are designed to seamlessly integrate with advanced communication systems, but there are some key differences.
- Schuberth C5: Pre-installed with HD speakers, two antennas, and a microphone. It is compatible with the SC2 communication system, which features Mesh 2.0 technology for virtually unlimited rider connections. Installation is simple and user-friendly.
- Shoei Neotec 3: Works with the SRL3 communication system, developed in collaboration with Sena. The SRL3 offers both Mesh Intercom™ and traditional Bluetooth connectivity for up to 24 riders. Its discreet design maintains the helmet’s aerodynamic look.
Winner: Both helmets excel in communication system integration, but the Schuberth C5’s pre-installed hardware offers greater convenience for riders.
Visor and Sun Visor
Both helmets include high-quality visors and integrated sun-visor, but the specifics vary slightly.
- Schuberth C5: Comes with a Pinlock 120 insert, offering top-tier anti-fog performance. The sun-visor is adjustable via a slider, but some riders may find the mechanism less refined.
- Shoei Neotec 3: Features a Pinlock Evo insert, which provides excellent anti-fog performance. The sun-visor is smooth and intuitive to operate, with ample coverage for various light conditions.
Winner: The Schuberth C5 excels in anti-fog performance, while the Shoei Neotec 3 stands out for its sun-visor usability.
Other Modular Helmets to Consider
If you’re exploring alternatives, consider these premium modular helmets:
- HJC RPHA 91 Carbon: Lightweight and aerodynamic with a luxurious interior, ideal for touring riders.
- Nolan X-1005 Ultra Carbon: Known for its dual homologation, advanced ventilation, and sleek carbon fibre design.
